-- Advertisement --

The Lieberman Effect

How much will one man affect health care reform?
Joe Lieberman

It’s hard to imagine that just two individuals could hold the fate of America’s health care in their hands. One in particular has Washington abuzz with talk of what he may do next and has lawmakers on both sides of the aisle clambering for his allegiance. Congressional Democrats are panic stricken, worrying they won’t be able to give Obama what he wants most for Christmas - health care reform - and it’s all because of one Independent senator.

For months, Connecticut Senator Joe Lieberman has been vocal about the health care debate. He was one of the original supporters of a Medicare buy-in option, plugging the idea while running for vice president on the Gore/Lieberman ticket in 2000.

Last weekend, Lieberman sent the Democrats into a tailspin when he announced in a television interview on the CBS NEWS program “Face the Nation” that he would not support the health care reform bill unless they abandon both the public option and Medicare expansion. Democrats thought they had reached a compromise with Lieberman last week and believed they were close to securing the 60 votes need to pass the controversial legislation.

Joining Lieberman on the show was Democrat Ben Nelson, who is against the bill due to his opposition to abortion. Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid met with Nelson over the weekend in an effort to try to work out a compromise and get the Nebraska senator on board. Both Lieberman and Nelson said the Democrats lack the votes needed to pass reform, frustrating Obama and prompting him to invite the full Democratic Caucus to the White House on Tuesday.

The power and influence of the Oval Office was on full display during the private meeting that lasted more than an hour. Obama’s focus: getting the final two holdouts to sign off on health care reform. And it appears he may have succeeded in getting at least one of the votes he was after. Some reports indicate Lieberman may be ready to throw his support to what’s left of the bill, which as far as some Democrats are concerned, is not much.

Prominent Democrat, Howard Dean, spoke out Tuesday, telling fellow Democrats to “kill the bill” because none of the important reforms the party had pushed for remain intact. We don’t know what will happen with the bill in the short term. This story changes almost hourly, but one thing is for sure: the Democrats won’t soon forget the power of the Lieberman effect and things could get nasty. A House Democrat has said Lieberman should be recalled, and liberals have even attacked his wife, attempting to get her fired from her position at the Susan G. Komen Breast Cancer Foundation.

In the end, if the final bill passes it will basically look the way Lieberman and Nelson want. While these men may or may not be enjoying their current position of power, regardless of how this story ends, you can bet Washington Democrats won’t forgive and forget the three-ring circus they’ve been party to the last few weeks at the hands of their ringmaster Lieberman.

 
COMMENTS & DISCUSSION (24) COMMENTS
Philip Shelton
Dec. 17, 2009
10:45 AM EST
Men amoung men. As always, only a few good men seem to grasp the true meaning of the task at hand. My hat is off to them.

angel
Dec. 17, 2009
10:45 AM EST
obama is a ethier want to destroy these country first by spending money to bancrupt our nation 2 is black and is hurt because of white man has done to the black man throug the years and third no less is muslim or christian dont know if he christian why hid did not swear on the bible and these other thing went they song the national song he did not saluted the american flag that for me is desrepecting all the fallen hero of these nation that has fight for that flag an our nation freedom.

Soeko Prasetyo
Dec. 17, 2009
10:45 AM EST
Health Care Reform is important, but should never be signed if it is not right for the American. We salute Senators Lieberman and Nelson who stick with the people's principal. It's the people's money!

Maureen Whalen
Dec. 17, 2009
10:45 AM EST
I want to know how much money this and the other senators received from the health care lobby that prevents them from helping common American people who have no insurance or any hope of getting health insurance...

Pete King
Dec. 17, 2009
10:45 AM EST
One who has morals and guts is not worried about the voices of the herd. A legacy, which is carefully managed by the beasts of said herd, is not a legacy at all; but that which lasts long enough to be called a legacy is that which is bestowed by time and not concession. More power to those two who have illuminated the power of God.

greyfox
Dec. 17, 2009
12:00 PM EST
The democrats would be wise to recognize that the Obama ego is the only driver for this bill. Polls show that most citizens do not want this bill enacted. Cutting health care costs sounds good and has support but the democrats are showing interest only in delivering a bill to meet another Obama created deadline while defeating such ideas as cutting drug costs. Why---Obama.....he made a deal with the drug companies to settle for a lesser reduction and he is fustrated that his earlier "mst have by" dates were not met.

Mike Salius
Dec. 17, 2009
12:00 PM EST
As a communications/PR consultant I have often heard people spout the erroneous fact that "any publicity is good publicity." It appears that Senator Liebermann subscribes to this fallacy as well. The fact is that bad publicity yields negative results - - especially publicity that reveals a public figure's hypocrisy or duplicity. The attention that he is attracting with his position on health care will haunt him and limit his ability as law maker going forward. I don't think it's possible any longer for his colleagues to trust his position on issues and I think the voting public (especially in Connecticut) feels the same way.

Leslie Harris
Dec. 17, 2009
12:00 PM EST
what a jerk Lieberman is, how do these self serving slobs get elected? I hope his comuppance is soon

Pello Smith
Dec. 17, 2009
02:00 PM EST
It is a sad day in America when the needs of the American people become less important than the wants of a few powerful corporations and individuals. It is no doubt that the powerful healthcare lobby has enriched the bank accounts of these two "democratic" senators and the entire Republican caucaus. This is why revolutions are waged. We need "people power" to rise up and return all those who have "sold" out to the lobbyist home for good.

LEW
Dec. 17, 2009
02:00 PM EST
My hat is off to the two senators, Lieberman and Nelson, for having the common sense to oppose this nightmare legislation. The nation cannot afford it, it's immoral, it's bald faced socialism, and it's likely un-constitutional. It is certainly nothing our founders would have espoused.

Edgar
Dec. 17, 2009
02:00 PM EST
When have to depend on a"Scumb-Bag" politisian to get what is ours any ways, you find that these slime-bucket/ legens in there own mind, always getting in the way, until someone pay them off.

Jamie Morvitz
Dec. 17, 2009
06:00 PM EST
As far as I know, for a while (though I don't know if this has changed recently), more of the public were coming around to the public option so that it was a majority of people. So why the holdup? What makes absolutely no sense to me is that Congressmen and some of the public are against the public option because of abortion. Abortion is going to happen whether the option to pay for it through a government health care is available or not. So really, saying you don't want the public option for that reason means that you are unconcerned with the fact that people are going to do it anyway and it is going to be more dangerous. Not only may the fetus' be destroyed, but now without the public option, the mother's life will be in danger as well. Yeah, that makes so much sense! Besides, the main purpose of the public option is to be competition with private insurance companies so the premiums can come down and people can actually afford health care. Everyone's concerned with the economy and costs of tax cuts and wars and yet there are still people who don't think this competition for a lower cost for health care is a good idea. I don't understand this at all.

Robert Whitley
Dec. 18, 2009
10:15 AM EST
I hope all of congress get thiers next November. I think poll after poll indicate that the American people do not want their interference due to incompetency. They totally screw up everything they touch. Why won't they push tort reform or allow buying drugs from Canada. You know why? I will tell you. Obama and his crony's are bought. All the Dem's have done over the past year is spend like drunkin sailors in a whore house. Unlike democrates I have morals and I will get down on my knees and pray that they are stopped.

EVALD PETERSON
Dec. 18, 2009
10:30 AM EST
THIS HEALTH CARE PROPOSAL IN UN CONSTUNTAL AND IS A TAKE OVER OF THE HEALTH OF THE NATION BY THE FEDERAL GOVERMENT. THE VOTERS OF THE US ARE 62 PERCENT AGAINST IT

Evald Peterson
Dec. 18, 2009
10:30 AM EST
I don't expect to see as it does not fit into your mind thoughts.

Linda
Dec. 18, 2009
10:30 AM EST
I think most people in favor of this bill believe they will get free health care...................WRONG! The State of Michigan has all kinds of insurance programs for people who can't afford insurance. They are now starting to set up free clinics where doctors volunteer their time to help these people. That is what America is all about. I am for reform but not a bill pushed through to apease the Dems before Christmas!

MARY RAINEY
Dec. 18, 2009
10:30 AM EST
IT SEEMS AS THOUGH THE RIGHT PEOPLE HAVEN'T SUFFERED YET AT THE HANDS OF THE REAL TERRORISTS, THE MEDICAL PROFESSION. THEY ARE THE ONES HOLDING OUR LIVES HOSTAGE FOR RANSOM. INSURANCE IS JUST A PLAYER IN THE GAME AND THE POLITICIANS ARE THE SCORE KEEPERS. THE MEDICAL PROFESSION HAS RAPED INSURANCE AND MEDICARE FOR YEARS, FORCING THE INSURANCE COMPANIES INTO A STRATEGIC DEFENSE PUTTING HUMAN BEINGS IN THE MIDDLE OF A ONGOING BATTLE BETWEEN TWO CAPITALIST ENTITIES. DOES ANYONE ELSE OUT THERE FIND THIS EVEN SLIGHTLY REPULSIVE, BESIDES MYSELF? JESUS CHIRST! BY THE WAY, WHO NEVER ASKED ANYONE FOR A INSURANCE CARD, WOULD MOST CERTIANLY REFER TO THEM AS THE MONEY CHANGERS WHOM HE CHASTIZED AND RAN OUT OF THE TEMPLES, DIDN'T HE? OH YEA, I FORGOT, SINCE MOST RELEGIOUS INSTITUTIONS ARE TAX FREE CAPITALIST VENTURES I CAN SEE HOW MOST OF THEM BEING RIGHT WING CAPITALISTS WOULD SUPPORT HEALING FOR HIRE. ONCE AGAIN, NOW THAT THE ISSUE IS PRO LIVING WHERE ARE YOU SO CALLED PRO LIFERS? HOW MANY MORE LIVING SOULS MUST SUFFER THE UNJUST AGONY OF FINANCIAL FAILURE, PAIN, LOSS OF QUALITY OF LIFE AND THE HUMILIATION OF THE INABLILTY TO PAY FOR EVEN THE MOST BASIC OF MEDICAL SERVICES, EVEN DEATH, BEFORE WE BEGIN TO SERIOUSLY IMPLEMENT A REAL PLAN THAT WE CAN EQUALLY SHARE THE BURDEN AND BENEFITS OF FOR HEALTH CARE? I GUARANTEE THAT IF THIS ISSUE WERE TO HIT THE HOMES OF ENOUGH OF OUR POLITICIANS WE WOULD SEE ACTION IN THIS MATTER. WHAT'S MORE WE CAN MAKE THAT HAPPEN. WE CAN CHOOSE TO REMOVE THE HEALTH CARE THAT WE PROVIDE THEM WITH THROUGH OUR TAX DOLLARS. WE NOT ONLY PAY FOR HEALTH CARE FOR THEM AND THEIR FAMILIES BUT WE CONTINUE TO PAY FOR THEIR HEALTH CARE WHEN THEY LEAVE AND ARE LONG GONE FROM OFFICE. THIS IS BLATANT ARISTROCRACY AND THERE IS NOTHING NOBEL ABOUT IT! HOW WOULD THEY FEEL IF WE TOOK HEALTH CARE AWAY FROM THEM? WE CAN DO IT. IT WILL TAKE A LOT OF TIME, FIGHT AND WILLPOWER BUT IF COMPLACENT AMERICANS WOULD RALLY TOGETHER WE COULD SEND CONGRESS AND REPRESENTATIVES LIKE LIEBERMAN A WAKE UP CALL.

jose
Dec. 18, 2009
10:30 AM EST
What is wrong with This president most of us americans oppose his health bill which is worthless, can't he get it if it was a good bill it would of passed a long time ago

Tommy Holliday Dec. 18, 2009
Dec. 18, 2009
10:30 AM EST
Way to go Joe, we need health care reform but not that one and it needs to be one where both democrats and republicans sit down together and agree on something and leave all the pork out of it, be nice to have a plan like they have.

A CONCERNED GRAMMA FOR MY GRANDCHILDREN
Dec. 18, 2009
10:30 AM EST
In all my 82 years I have never seen such a bunch of our elected officials want to ram down the throats of hard working people all the spending on a health care plan of over 2000 pages without reading the bill. Where are the democratic leaders whom we elected to look out for the good of the people any more. We have a give-me mentality in this great nation of ours who want hard working people to pay for all their expenses. Where do these people think the money comes from. THIS IS SAD. KILL THE BILL. Good for the men who can still see what is the right thing and not pass a bill where certain congressmen get 300 billion just to sign something for the money. If you want to talk about greed - look at all the bill signers who do not know what they are signing and just sign it because Obama says to. My health care is very good for me - al-though I only take one small pill a day. GOOD GOING LIEBERMAN

bethovan
Dec. 21, 2009
10:30 AM EST
I don't know if any of you realize it or not, but Thank God, that John McCain, Lieberman, are fighting this Health Care Bill from Going Through, if they put all these people on Medicare, including the Aliens that are here, Medicare says no one will be in sured, in 1 1/2 years, not good for our Senior Citizens, and all of your parents, will be without any kind of medical help at all, we will stand in lines to see a physician for days, just like they stood in linbes in the depresion time of 1929. There are 75 million people on Social Security and Medicare, what happens to all of those people? has anyone out here thought about it? NO, I pray the Bill does not go through for all the disabled, mental and physical people, and elderly people. Not to mention Obama promised all the senior citizens he would not touch Medicare, or Social Security, AND THAT IS WHAT HE IS DOING., DESTROYING OUR AMERICA.

alina syed
Dec. 21, 2009
10:30 AM EST
u all are basterd bcz u r responsible to destroy pakistan the taliban are your men y u dont do your politics y u interfior in metters of pakistan u r stupid idiod bitch obama is nonsense ihate him y he get award of peace but obama is who send 30000army to afghanistan to destroy its peace men women and small childs die shame on you amircans obama is muslim but shame pakistani thinks obama is muslim so he has justice with them but o bama is dad of bush

Belinda
Dec. 21, 2009
05:00 PM EST
Liberman, needs to grow up... Ask yourselves why would a nation not want to take care it's own people... We are the only country who do not offer health care for it's citizens, yet we expect the people to fight when we are at war... Think about it!

Ilen
Jan. 05, 2010
11:45 AM EST
Wake up B we are the best Nation in the World. If your are not happy with it then feel free to leave. We have one of the best insurance plans and medical Drs. We may need a few adjustments but not a take over by the Goverment or a total redue. We have Medicade extend it to the uninsured. Have you taken the time to read this bill or talked to a responsible and knowledgeable person about it?

Share your thoughts on the story by adding your comments below. Comments containing profanity, derogatory language, or any form of advertisement will not be approved. Comments will be reviewed by the site's editorial team, so your post may not appear for up to 24 hours. Thank you for your patience.

POST YOUR RESPONSE
 
 
Balance of Power

Track the United States government with updates on the three branches of government.

The Issues